In The Top Ten Most Desirable Magic Cards, According to Gatherer, Part One, we witnessed six of the finest pieces of cardboard ever to grace the game of Magic. Those cards were powerful, flexible, open-ended and fun. Well… fun at least for the person who cast them. It takes a certain caliber of cards to get a consistent five star rating on Gatherer. Card number eight, for example, Gaea’s Cradle, ranked in at a 4.842 community rating out of 219 votes. That means if seven people gave this the worst possible score (one-half a star), then the other 212 voters gave it a full five star rating (which is not how it went down, since the math is an approximation). These cards have a higher density of stars than the Messier 80 Globular Cluster in the constellation Scorpio (Oh snap! I went there!).
Despite that, there are seven cards that have garnered even more respect from the Magic playing community than that. Among them is: